This is one of the most popular high end sushi restaurants in Tokyo and I cannot for the life of me understand why.

The Ikura and Katsuo were pretty good. 9.5/10. The rest were 7/10 at best. Nothing was the best in its category.

What really made this experience absolute trash was the chef and the other customers.

For those who don’t know, there are 2 rounds. 18:00 and 20:30. You wait outside of the door and they call your name and seat you. The problem is that the moment they started calling names, the 3 other groups literally ran into the door cutting the queue as if they weren’t going to call everybody. Alright, not that bad yet, but troubling signs for the meal to come.

For the sake of simplicity, there were 5 groups. We’ll call them group A, B, C, us, and D.

So group A were big regulars. I think it was their third night in a row and they brought a bottle of Dom and bought 3 other bottles of white. The moment they sit down, they pour half a glass of Dom for themselves and for the chef and had him down the half glass. Immediately followed by 3 more glasses. They kept on going and the chef downed 5-6 glasses in a row before even starting.

Group C were a group of 65+ year old predators (also regulars) openly talking about buying young and potentially underaged Thai girls and offering on bringing the chef to a “girl’s bar” where they will “prepare” a lady. The chef was badmouthing his own girlfriend while Saito san came out and told the chef to go with the customers to the “girl’s bar”.

Group B joined in and made the chef down a red as well.

Chef (the apprentice to Saito san) was dropping rice and knocking over tools the entire night. He even dropped an entire sushi on the floor. He also messed up a fish, audibly went oops, then went ahead and served the fish anyway. He was also overtly playing favourites giving bigger (2x) portions to groups A, B, and C. He would forget what he served and mix up what he was serving.

At the end, Group A bought a round of Nihonshu (sake) for the entire restaurant, then mixed it into a wine glass with a different bottle of white and made the assistant drink it, who immediately ran into the back to vomit after drinking it.

Am I crazy for thinking that this is absolutely unacceptable? We’re paying 48,000¥ per person for this meal that feels like “ok” sushi and a disgusting circus of a dining experience. Is it too much to expect that either the chef or Saito san himself put their foot down and stop this kind of behaviour?

0/10 dining experience and would not repeat.

by nazomawarisan

19 Comments

  1. ladylondonderry on

    That sounds absolutely unacceptable. The customers are one set of issues that I’d hope a well-managed restaurant would handle. But the chef? That’s bizarre and gross.

    Was everyone there completely shitfaced?

  2. 1. Ikura and Nori (this was great)
    2. Katsuo (this was great)
    3. Tako and Awabi with Awabi liver (this was good)
    4. Nodoguro (this was mediocre)
    5. Tai
    6. Kue
    7. Kohada
    8. Akami
    9. Chutoro (he mistakenly told us this was Otoro, but it isn’t)
    10. Otoro
    11. Shin Ika
    12. Kuruma Ebi
    13. Aji
    14. Hamaguri
    15. Murasaki Uni
    16. Anago
    17. Not pictured because I was already beyond pissed here, they had the Maki and the egg.

  3. Sounds like a fun night out to me.

    Did you make sure to put your pinky in the air whilst you sipped your sake?

  4. Big yikes. Sounds like someone forgot who the customer is and what level of service folks are paying for

  5. Shocking that a place “regarded” so highly would allow this to happen. #4 on Japan OAD? You can’t imagine this is the only time it operates like this.

  6. Booze at omakase bothers me, period.

    When I went to Sukiyabashi Jiro, it was apparent that booze was there for people who weren’t there to eat.

    What an awful experience. I like booze, quite a bit, but I’m not going to drink at that kind of experience ever. The fact that the chefs got drunk is so disappointing

  7. Ouch. I’ve had similar experiences at other restaurants in Tokyo and will never visit them again because of it. I feel a lot of this type of behavior is confined to certain neighborhoods that seem to attract this type of clientele. Almost all my poor experiences are in a small swath of Roppongi/Nishiazabu. I’m am very reluctant to try new places in that area unless someone I trust vouches for it.

  8. drink_and_driv on

    This seems to be the trend, not just at Saito but some of the other traditionally renowned sushiyas I’ve been to, post-COVID. Hope you get a better experience at a different place next time.

  9. Truly shocking. A few friends visit often and never heard such things, so let’s still hope this was an outlier… That being said this is the risk of turning the restaurant into a private club…

    One thing though. How comes Saito-san didn’t prepare the sushi??

Leave A Reply